Prompt: Should a city library end late fees? Evidence includes collection costs and patron return rates. Which thesis is most defensible?

Prompt: Should the school adopt a four-day week? Evidence covers attendance, activities, and childcare. Which thesis is most defensible?

Prompt: Evaluate whether a documentary uses archival footage ethically. Which thesis would best guide the essay?

Prompt: Should the district require community service for graduation? Which thesis is most defensible?

Prompt: Should a school limit phone use during lunch? Which thesis creates the strongest line of reasoning?

Prompt: Analyze whether satire strengthens a political essay. Which thesis is most defensible?

Prompt: Should local newspapers publish anonymous opinion essays? Which thesis is most defensible?

Prompt: Should schools publicly rank students by GPA? Which thesis best supports an extended argument?

Prompt: Evaluate whether a novel's nonlinear structure is effective. Which thesis is strongest?

Prompt: Should a museum return artifacts acquired under colonial rule? Which thesis is most defensible?

Draft: "Social media ruins civic debate." Evidence is one school's survey and class discussion threads. Which revision fits the evidence?

Draft: "The new bus schedule solved tardiness." Evidence shows an 8% decline in first-period tardies at two high schools, with no middle school data. Which revision is best?

Draft: "Poetry units make students more empathetic." Evidence is reflective journals from one English IV class. Which revision is appropriately qualified?

Draft: "Open-campus lunch is unsafe." Evidence includes one semester of incident reports, a student survey, and traffic warnings. Which revision fits best?

Draft: "Banning single-use plastics fixes pollution." Evidence is a cafeteria waste audit and cost estimates for reusable dishes. Which revision fits the evidence?

Draft: "AI writing tools destroy originality." Evidence is teacher comments on 20 revised essays and students' process notes. Which revision is strongest?

Thesis: Later start times should be adopted because sleep gains improve learning despite transportation challenges. Which order builds the argument?

Thesis: A speech's repeated questions turn the audience from observers into responsible actors. Which claim sequence is most logical?

Thesis: A novel's two settings interact to show freedom as both escape and belonging. Which order builds a unified analysis?

Thesis: The city should convert an unused mall into housing. Which order creates the clearest line of reasoning?

Thesis: The dress code should be revised, not abolished, because vague language invites unequal enforcement. Which order best supports it?

Thesis: A poem's shift from measured syntax to fragments makes grief audible. Which order builds the analysis?

Thesis: An editorial's concession increases credibility, but its analogy weakens the argument. Which order is strongest?

Thesis: Bilingual signage should expand because it improves access without replacing English communication. Which order builds the case?

Thesis: Financial literacy should be required because no required course covers practical money decisions. The essay has established course topics. Which paragraph claim should follow?

Thesis: The campus should keep the arts requirement because it develops interpretation skills across disciplines. After its history, which claim advances the argument?

Thesis: The narrator's uncertainty is the source of the story's suspense. After the opening's conflicting memories, which claim should come next?

Thesis: A renewable-energy ordinance is justified because long-term savings outweigh initial costs. After explaining upfront costs, which claim advances the line?

Thesis: The speaker's concession prepares a skeptical audience for refutation. After establishing the audience's skepticism, which claim advances the analysis?

Thesis: A grading policy should allow limited revisions because revision rewards learning without erasing accountability. After the current penalty system, which claim fits next?